Why Does Your Therapist’s Theory Matter?

Kathryn Price, LPC-Associate, CCPS-Candidate, EMDR

When choosing a therapist, you may look at their specialties, experience, personality, or the populations they work with. You may also come across terms like Adlerian, psychodynamic, cognitive behavioral, person-centered, or systems-based therapy.

These terms describe, at least in part, a therapist’s theoretical orientation and while you certainly do not need to understand your therapist’s theory to benefit from therapy, knowing a little about it can give you insight into how your therapist understands you and how they believe change happens.

What Is a Therapeutic Theory?

Every therapist has a lens through which they understand human behavior.

A therapeutic theory helps answer questions such as:

  • Why do people behave the way they do?

  • How do our past experiences affect us today?

  • What causes emotional distress?

  • What creates lasting change?

  • How important are our thoughts, emotions, bodies, relationships, culture, or childhood experiences?

Different theories answer these questions differently.

For example, one therapist may place significant importance on how your early relationships continue to influence your present-day patterns. Another may focus primarily on how your current thoughts influence your emotions and behaviors. Someone else may understand distress through relationships, family systems, the nervous system, or the ways we seek meaning and connection.

A therapist’s theory therefore does more than provide techniques. It influences what they notice, the questions they ask, the goals they help you develop, and the ways they approach change.

Do You Need to Agree With Your Therapist’s Theory?

Not necessarily

Some people may find it comforting to know that the way their therapist understands change closely aligns with their own beliefs. If you already believe that understanding your childhood is important, for example, working with a therapist who also values exploring early experiences may feel natural. When you and your therapist have similar ideas about change, you may also find that the goals you set and the techniques used in therapy make sense to you.

For others, working with a therapist who approaches things somewhat differently can be helpful.

Maybe you are in a transitional period of your life and beginning to question how you have always understood yourself. Maybe the strategies you have relied on are no longer working. Or perhaps you do not yet know what you believe creates change.

A different perspective can sometimes help us see something we could not see from inside our existing worldview.

Neither approach is inherently better.

More importantly, you should feel safe enough to disagree, ask questions, and tell your therapist when something does not fit. Therapy should not require you to adopt your therapist’s worldview.

What are the Major Families of Therapy?

There are hundreds of individual theories and therapeutic approaches, and therapists may organize them somewhat differently. Broadly, many approaches draw from larger traditions such as:

  • Psychodynamic approaches, which often explore unconscious processes, early experiences, attachment, and recurring patterns.

  • Behavioral approaches, which examine learned behaviors and how our environments reinforce or change them.

  • Cognitive and cognitive-behavioral approaches, which explore relationships among thoughts, emotions, and behaviors.

  • Humanistic and experiential approaches, which emphasize the individual’s subjective experience, capacity for growth, meaning, authenticity, and the therapeutic relationship.

  • Systemic approaches, which understand individuals within relationships, families, communities, and larger systems.

  • Holistic and integrative approaches, which may consider multiple aspects of the person including the mind, body, relationships, environment, culture, and, when meaningful to the client, spirituality.

Many therapists do not practice exclusively from one theory. They may integrate several approaches while having one primary theory that guides how they conceptualize their clients and the process of change.

Theory Does Not Exist Outside of Culture

There is another important piece of this conversation: therapeutic theories were created by people, and people exist within cultures and historical periods.

Many foundational Western psychotherapy theories were developed in social and academic environments that centered White, Western, male perspectives.

As a result, some traditional concepts may not adequately account for experiences related to race, ethnicity, gender, sexuality, socioeconomic status, disability, religion, immigration, discrimination, community, or other cultural identities and experiences.

A theory should therefore be a lens…not a rulebook that overrides someone's lived experience.

A behavior that one theoretical framework labels unhealthy may make considerably more sense when we understand the person's culture, environment, experiences of oppression, relationships, or need for safety. Similarly, ideas about independence, family, boundaries, success, emotional expression, spirituality, and healing can look very different across cultures.

As our understanding of psychology continues to develop, our theories and the ways therapists use them should develop too.

Part of culturally responsive therapy is recognizing the limitations of the theories we were taught, remaining curious about experiences different from our own, and being willing to adapt our understanding rather than forcing someone's experience to fit neatly inside a theory.

Therapeutic Approaches That More Intentionally Center Culture

The limitations of traditional theories do not mean that culture has been ignored within the counseling field. Multicultural and culturally responsive approaches have developed specifically to help therapists understand clients within the context of their identities, communities, values, and lived experiences.

A few examples include:

Multicultural Counseling Theory, which places culture at the center of how we understand both the client and the counseling relationship. Rather than assuming that one definition of health, independence, relationships, or emotional expression applies to everyone, the therapist considers the client's worldview alongside their own. It requires therapists to examine their own assumptions and biases so that cultural differences are not automatically interpreted as problems that need to be corrected.

Culturally Responsive Cognitive Behavioral Therapy. Traditional Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) explores how our thoughts, emotions, and behaviors interact. Culturally responsive applications of CBT retain this foundation while intentionally considering the client's cultural context. The goal is not to abandon the principles of CBT, but to apply them without separating the individual from the world they actually live in.

Narrative Therapy offers another way of understanding people that can create space for culture and identity. Narrative approaches explore the stories we develop about ourselves and the meanings we attach to our experiences.

Should You Ask Your Therapist About Their Theory?

Short answer: you can.

You might ask:

  • “What kind of therapy do you practice?”

  • “How do you understand why people develop the patterns they do?”

  • “What do you believe creates change in therapy?”

  • “What might therapy with you actually look like?”

However, you do not need to know your therapist's theoretical orientation, and you certainly do not need to become an expert in counseling theory before starting therapy.

What matters most is whether you feel comfortable with your therapist, whether you feel heard and respected, and whether the work you are doing together feels meaningful and appropriate for you.

But understanding a therapist's theoretical orientation can give you another piece of information when deciding whether they may be a good fit.

Because ultimately, theory influences how your therapist sees the world and how they will work with you as you begin to understand yours.

Next
Next

How to Choose a Trauma Therapist: 10 Questions to Ask Before You Begin